The fall production is a small dramatic show that in past years has ranged from Shakespeare to dinner theater.  Fall drama productions are typically much smaller than the spring musical. In some years, the students – with the support of the Fine Arts Boosters – have staged a dinner theatre production such as "Murder Me Always," where food and fun are combined. In recent years, the students have chosen to do "A Midsummer Night’s Dream," "Acting Can Be Murder" and the comedy “Noises Off” for their Fall Drama production.

The Musical is ideal for students interested in acting, singing, playing in pit band, and being involved in technical theatre such as lights, makeup, set painting, and costumes. In recent years, the John Bapst Players have staged “Guys and Dolls” as well as “42nd Street,” both lauded and applauded by the John Bapst audience.